The roofing industry has seen significant changes over the years, and one of the notable shifts is the decline in the use of organic shingles. At Steadfast Roofing, we aim to educate our clients about the evolution of roofing materials and the best options available today. This article delves into the history, current status, and alternatives to organic shingles.

What Are Organic Shingles?
Organic shingles were formerly a popular choice for roofing, constructed from cellulose fibers and other organic materials such as felt. They were treated with asphalt for waterproofing, then coated with additional asphalt and covered with ceramic granules. Although they were widely used at one time, organic shingles had notable drawbacks, including a propensity to ignite and degrade rapidly under harsh weather conditions.
Why They Were Popular
- Made from organic materials
- Provided a classic, timeless look
- Initially perceived as environmentally friendly
Why Are Organic Shingles Hard to Find?
Today, organic shingles are virtually obsolete. Most manufacturers stopped producing them around 2008 due to their poor durability and susceptibility to weather damage. Homeowners discovered that these shingles did not last as long as advertised, leading to numerous class action lawsuits against manufacturers. As a result, the industry shifted towards more durable and cost-effective alternatives like fiberglass shingles.
Reasons for Decline
- Rapid deterioration in harsh weather
- Fire hazards due to their composition
- Legal issues and class action lawsuits
Are Organic Shingles Still in Production?
Organic shingles are no longer in production. For homeowners with historic buildings or old roofs still using organic shingles, replacement with modern materials is the only option. If your roof has organic shingles and suffers damage, the entire roof typically needs to be replaced since individual organic shingles are no longer available.
Replacement Challenges
- No availability of individual shingles for repairs
- Entire roof replacement often necessary
Alternatives to Organic Shingles
As organic shingles became less common, a range of new roofing materials was introduced, providing enhanced durability and extended lifespans. Here are some alternatives to consider:
Metal Roofs
Metal roofs are known for their durability, light weight, and energy efficiency. They perform well under extreme weather conditions and have a long lifespan.
Wooden/Cedar Shingles
Offering a classic and rustic appearance, wooden or cedar shingles provide excellent insulation, helping to keep homes warm in various weather conditions.
Synthetic Asphalt Shingles
Constructed from a blend of fiberglass and plastic polymers, these shingles are durable, weather-resistant, and fire-resistant, making them a long-lasting option.
Slate
Slate roofing, made from natural stone, is highly durable and fire-resistant. It also provides excellent insulation and has a long lifespan.
Composite Spanish Barrel Tiles
These tiles replicate the appearance of traditional clay tiles but are made from plastic and rubber. They are lightweight, durable, and energy-efficient.
Conclusion
Organic shingles had their time in the spotlight but have been replaced by more durable and sustainable roofing options. If you need to replace your old organic shingles, modern alternatives offer better performance and longevity. At Steadfast Roofing, we are dedicated to providing top-quality roofing services and educating our clients in Ruskin, FL, and surrounding areas.
For more information on the best roofing materials, visit our blog on the top 3 ventilation solutions for metal roofs.